|
Post by luro2020 on Jun 2, 2017 17:20:16 GMT
I found this in r/short, "this commercial instead of portraying the short man as a walking bundle of stereotypes, features a cool and suave short man www.reddit.com/r/short/comments/6eqvmq/kudos_to_stella_artois_for_doing_something_that/dicbhgp/. Some of the most spot on comments. "Cool, but one observation I'll make - the only wide shot that shows us this man standing directly in opposition to a woman from a straight angle employs a woman that is exactly his height, not a centimeter taller... Every other shot, while certainly showing women who are visibly taller than him, doesn't juxtapose it in the traditional wide shot intersecting angle like the last shot with the shortest woman. (lotta low upward angles and so forth...) It's a step in the right direction, but clearly they still hesitate to violate the taboo completely." That's interesting. I viewed it totally differently. I think the final moment of the ad shows that the woman he is flirting with is clearly taller than him. They don't seem to be the same height at all to me. (Check out their eye levels) Plus, his shortness seems exaggerated in the scene where everyone gathers around to see the magic trick. Everyone towers over him, but he was the center of attention." What can I say?GA is a lost cause, still posting on a sub trying to fight heightism full of people who are unaware of it, trying to fight against us, and making it 1000x harder to get any real work done, but this commerical is definately a big jump.
|
|
|
Post by luro2020 on Jun 2, 2017 17:21:59 GMT
I found this in r/short, "this commercial instead of portraying the short man as a walking bundle of stereotypes, features a cool and suave short man" www.reddit.com/r/short/comments/6eqvmq/kudos_to_stella_artois_for_doing_something_that/dicbhgp/. Some of the most spot on comments. "Cool, but one observation I'll make - the only wide shot that shows us this man standing directly in opposition to a woman from a straight angle employs a woman that is exactly his height, not a centimeter taller...
Every other shot, while certainly showing women who are visibly taller than him, doesn't juxtapose it in the traditional wide shot intersecting angle like the last shot with the shortest woman. (lotta low upward angles and so forth...)
It's a step in the right direction, but clearly they still hesitate to violate the taboo completely."
That's interesting. I viewed it totally differently. I think the final moment of the ad shows that the woman he is flirting with is clearly taller than him. They don't seem to be the same height at all to me. (Check out their eye levels)
Plus, his shortness seems exaggerated in the scene where everyone gathers around to see the magic trick. Everyone towers over him, but he was the center of attention."What can I say?GA is a lost cause, still posting on a sub trying to fight heightism full of people who are unaware of it, trying to fight against us, and making it 1000x harder to get any real work done, but this commerical is definately a big jump.
|
|
|
Post by toughlimbs on Jun 3, 2017 12:48:50 GMT
This short video still isn't convincing enough. This shows that a short man has to be absolutely, over-the-top incredible in magic the first time he enters the room. Remember when a short man has to do three times more work than the tallers do if he wants to be noticed? Imagine a tall man who's taller than everyone in the room, and as soon as he enters the room, everyone would just stare at him with awe. He doesn't need to perform incredible skills, he just steps into the room, and all he had to do is stand up straight while showing "confidence".
I don't want a short man to have to do all the damn work to make himself noticeable.
|
|